The San Francisco 49ers entered the 2025 offseason with babies to bathe and bills to pay, literally.
They shed nine starters (Deebo Samuel, Aaron Banks, Dre Greenlaw, Kyle Juszczyk among them) in what felt like a cap-driven fire sale. GM John Lynch admitted it was “a little uneasy” but necessary to get younger and cheaper ahead of Brock Purdy’s massive contract, and to preserve flexibility for the future.
What Changed, Roster-Wise for the 49ers
Big Niners Contracts Locked In
- Brock Purdy inked a six-year, ~$270 million extension, though it technically starts in 2026, keeping his cap hit manageable now. He leads the locker room with his presence and professional approach (shown by showing up early to OTAs) .
- George Kittle followed suit with a four-year, $76.4 million deal, making him the highest-paid tight end in NFL history, $40 million guaranteed.
- Fred Warner also locked in a three-year, $63 million extension, highest-paid linebacker in the league, solidifying the veteran spine.
Youth Wave & Draft Investments
- The 2025 draft produced 11 new players expected to fight for starting jobs, DT Alfred Collins, CB Upton Stout, DT C.J. West are among those who could step into big roles immediately.
- Luke Farrell, signed as a blocking TE, is viewed as key to help Kittle stay a threat in the passing game by lifting his blocking burden.
Veteran In & Out Flow
- The 49ers brought in vet OL Andre Dillard, swing-OT Nicholas Petit Frère along with other role players to fill in gaps left by offseason departures. Notably, Kevin Givens was retained, showing some continuity in the D line.
- They avoided bringing in major defensive linemen in free agency, betting on rookies and under the radar signings to step up.
Strengths & Positives
- Culture Reset, Reduced Drama Purdy, Kittle, Warner and co. set the tone by getting deals done without controversies. Kittle noted that absence of contract holdouts or QB controversy has kept the locker room healthy.
- Cap Strategy By restructuring contracts and declining big off-season splashes, they’re saving nearly $46 million cap space rolling into 2026, positioning for aggressive upgrades then.
- Rookie Depth Appeal John Lynch repeatedly stated the exits funded internal competition, youngsters, and draft capital instead of overpaying aging vets.
- Still anchored by core voices. Purdy leads quietly, Kittle and Warner vocally. Steve Young praised the offseason as well-handled, citing extensions and drafting as evidence of a “tremendous NFL offseason”.
Risks & Negatives
- Loss of Experience & Cohesion Many experts remain indifferent, some argue the 49ers lost too many veteran starters to bet on unproven youth. The risk: system knowledge and on-field chemistry take time.
- Weak Spots (Still) Sports Illustrated flagged O line and guard particularly as weak areas, plus the trade of Jordan Mason, questioned as “the worst move” of the offseason si.com.
- Uncertainty in Execution Despite retaining Kevin Givens, the front seven definitely feels young. The boldness of relying heavily on rookies and backups could result in early-season growing pains.
Can This Be a Championship Year for San Francisco?
Look, you know I don’t mess around with spin. The missing nine starters are real, and the 6–11 finish from last season wasn’t a fluke. But Purdy, Kittle, and Warner remain elite. Shanahan wants to create competition at OG, nickel corner, tackle depth, and more, and that fire under vets and rookies could yield high-level play if they gel early.
Still, championship-caliber teams in the NFL depend on veteran cohesion and playoff-tested depth. This roster’s leaning young and boosts long-term hope more than instant success, per SI’s take that they might not be worse, but are hardly winners yet.
Bottom Line
This offseason was bold, necessary and lean, a strategic reset. I’m skeptical that these moves automatically jump-start a Super Bowl run in 2025. But if the rookies wake up early, the O line holds, and the leadership core remains healthy? Yes, the 49ers can crash the NFC’s elite bracket. It’s high-risk, moderate yield, with upside if the culture shift sticks.
I expect plenty of swagger still in the locker room. Championship year? Possible. Probable? Not without fast growth from new faces. We are talking about the San Francisco 49ers. Anything is possible.
Author
